Reevaluating Monetary policy in an Age of Uncertainty: Embracing Complexity

On March 26, 2025, William White gave the final lecture in the Macroeconomic Policy series sponsored by the Global Risk Institute in Toronto. He began by noting some of the undesirable outcomes associated with flexible inflation targetting in the advanced market economies; rising price levels, very high levels of private and public debt, rising inequality and slower potential growth. These outcomes could end in a serious crisis, an unintended consequence arising from the fact that  the inflation targetting framework rests on false assumptions about how the economy actually works. It is not a simple, static, linear, deterministic system seeking “equilibrium” but a complex, adaptive system (CAS) with potentially dangerous “tipping points” and no equilibrium. Embracing this fact immediatly leads to practical lessons about how to prevent crises,  how to manage the buildup of systemic stress and how to manage crises when they do arise. White then looked at many of the changes already proposed for how the current framework might be improved. He  concluded that the proposals recently made by Claudio Borio (OMFIF) and the BIS (Annual Report) best reflected what an explicit CAS framework would recommend

 

https://globalriskinstitute.org/event/rethinking-monetary-policy-adapting-central-bank-approaches-in-2025-and-beyond/#embedded-video

 

 

Posted by williamw in Presentations

The evolution of monetary policy in an age of uncertainty

William White made a Zoom presentation to a group of central bank econometric model builders on 23 January, 2025. The presentation was organized by the Better Policy Project which is collaborating with the Central Bank of Armenia in devising a new “Prudent Risk Management Approach to Price Stability”. White began by noting that a new approach to monetary policy is  required because the approach followed over recent decades has created ever larger financial bubbles.  The Prudent Risk Management Framework reflects many recent suggestions for improving the monetary policy framework. It recommends reliance on alternative scenarios, incorporating uncertainty and non-linearities, recognizing endogenous money and financial spillovers, and the importance of supply side developments. There are links below to White’s slides and presention.

LaxtonCBEJan2024

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GNqZGICzNps

Posted by williamw in Presentations

Panel Chairman’s Remarks at a Colloquium in Honour of Claudio Borio

A Colloquium was held on 22 November, 2024, at the Bank for International Settlements in Basel, in honour of Claudio Borio who retired from the BIS at the end of the year. The BIS will in the near future be posting the comments made by a large number of participants who came from all over the world to honour the many contributions made by Claudio to “the art of central banking” over many decades. William White was honoured to be asked to Chair the last panel of the day on monetary policy. His opening comments are attached.

 

BISClaudioPanel3
Posted by williamw in Presentations

Is a serious global debt crisis likely?

This question was adressed by a number of economists in the Summer 2024 edition of The Internationl Economy. William White (page 25) noted that the global economy is a complex, adaptive system and such systems often break down. We have had three major, global recessions since 1990 and they have all arisen from the financial sector. In each case, a sharp easing of monetary policy led to a debt buildup that then contributed to the next financial crisis as interest rates rose again.  Moreover, the credit granted as a counterpart to this debt has increasingly been granted by non-regulated entities. We do not know who has lent to whom. Against this backdrop, we now seem likely to encounter a number of inflationary pressures arisisng from secular forces; demographics, deglobalisation, climate change etc. A future, global debt crisis now seems more than likely.

 

InternationalEconomyTIE_Su24_GlobalDebtSymp

 

Posted by williamw in Articles, Press

Central banks need escape route from cycle of boom and bust

In his FT article of 1 November, 2024, John Plender made favourable reference to my most recent publication “Why the monetary framework in advanced countries needs fundamental reform”. It has been published as a chapter in the book “The age of debt bubbles”, edited by Max Rangely and published by Springer. Plender concludes that we urgently need debate on excessive monetary easing and the neglect of credit and debt developments. I totally agree, and would add (see my recent AEI presentation) that central banks have essentially ignored supply side developments as well.

https://www.ft.com/content/72b48b7d-ec17-4135-aa40-98b96eec2e64

Posted by williamw in Press, References

Grading the Negative Rate Experiment

A panel of economists responded to this challenge in the Spring Edition of  “The International Economy”. The panelists assessment were almost evenly divided between “A” and “F”  with an equal balance of division across all the letters in between. William White aligned himself with those giving an “F” ranking. While negative rates did not lead to the catastrophic outcomes suggested by some, they constituted an extension of the ultra-easy monetary policies in place since the Great Financial Crisis. White believes these policies were fundamentally misguided, leaving us exposed to both “financial dominance” and “fiscal dominance”.

InternationalEconomyGrading the Negative Rate ExperimentJune 2024

Posted by williamw in Articles

Is the Federal Reserve Behind the Curve?

On 8 October the American Enterprise Institute hoste a panel, chaired by Alex Polack, featuring (in order) Don Kohn, William White, Nathan Sheets and Desmond Lachman. White first evaluated the issue from the shorter-term perspective seemingly preferred both by analysts and the Federal Reserve itself. He concluded that the arguments for easing cautiously, if at all, dominated those for easing aggressively. He then went on to assert that a longer term perspective was required in this evaluation because, in Hyman Minsky’s words, “short term stability breeds longer term instability”. The Fed and central banks more generally have always been behind the curve because they have paid chronic inattention to supply side issues and to the longer term implications of thier policies for financial stability. Looking forward, negative supply shocks will increase the risks of a “tipping point” into either deflation (arising from excessive private debt) or high inflation (arising from excessive public debt).

https://www.aei.org/events/is-the-federal-reserve-behind-the-curve/

Posted by williamw in Presentations

Moving from an Age of Plenty to an Age of Scarcity

Wiliam White was interviewed by Ed D’Agostino of Mauldin Economics on  August 2, 2024. The conversation was centered around White’s view that a combination of negative supply shocks, and the need for massive expenditures to confront national security, environmental and other requirements, would in the end have to squeeze consumer expenditures. Higher interest rates would be part of the process for doing this. Transitioning to an Age of Scarcity will create formidable political challenges to the democratic order. The interview itself, and the transcript, are attached below.

 

EdD'Agastino(!)240808-gmu-transcript-william-white

https://youtu.be/d2GG2u7agsE

Posted by williamw in Interviews, Press

Sleepwalking towards a polycrisis? Spillover problems in complex systems

William White holds a PhD from the University of Manchester, and on 26 May partcipated in a fundraiser for other graduates of that university. His keynote presentation described the bad path we are on in the economic, domestic political, geopolitical and environmental spheres, and how things might well get worse. Not least, troubles in one system can destabilise the other systems. After analysing the various forces impeding meaningful policy chage, White gave a broad outline of what needs to be done to move forward, regardless.

 

TorontoManchesterPolycrisisTorontoUofManchester

Posted by williamw in Presentations